The acceptance rate isn't the point
When people test it, requests with and without a message usually get about the same acceptance rate. Sometimes no message even does a little better. If acceptances were the goal, you could stop there.
They aren't the goal. The goal is not to collect numbers and see how many connections you can pile up. It is to make real connections that turn into direct messages and, ideally, a Zoom call to network. That is what the platform is for.
Who accepts a blank request
Think about the kind of person who accepts a request with no message. Often it is someone who doesn't really care, who accepts everyone to build their numbers. They don't know who you are. They may suspect you are automated, or on a free account that ran out of notes.
That last suspicion is reasonable. LinkedIn's help center says a free account can add a personalized message to up to three connection requests a month (another of its help pages says five), while Premium members can personalize all of them. Each note is limited to 200 characters.
Who accepts a note
If the acceptance rate is about the same either way, the people who accept a request with a real message in it are more likely to be people who will actually interact with you. You have already started a conversation, and they chose to say yes to it.
Over hundreds of requests, that difference in who connects matters far more than a point or two of acceptance rate.
What to write
Ideally, each note is personal to the person, written in an authentic, real way. If you can't do that for every request, personalize it in some way anyway. LinkedIn's own advice is to keep it short and specific: how you found the person or what you have in common, why you want to connect now, and a polite tone.
Once they accept, the next step is turning that into a conversation. Here is how I move LinkedIn messages to a Zoom call.
