Lead with real curiosity
Don't pitch. The first message should ask a high level question in your area of expertise, one you are genuinely curious about.
There is research behind this. In a 2017 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Karen Huang and colleagues at Harvard found that people who ask more questions, especially follow up questions, are better liked by the people they talk with. The paper is titled "It doesn't hurt to ask: Question-asking increases liking".
Make the first question easy to answer
In the first message I use a simple either or, or yes or no, question. One example for a tech founder asked whether they were in the "I've got it handled" crew or the "please make the blinking lights stop" crew when it comes to their servers. Another, for a COO, asked whether getting help from the small business support ecosystem had felt straightforward or fragmented.
Those are easy to answer in a few seconds, and that is the point. Save the open ended questions for the call.
Use their language too. I was messaging people around Boston, and people there say "greater Boston," not "the Boston metro area." Getting that wrong tells them you are an outsider.
Keep it human
Keep it short and read it out loud. The tone I want is somewhere between a text and an email, the way you would talk to a coworker by the water cooler. Full sentences are optional. Always end with a question.
When I was working on one of these messages with someone, we found a typo and decided to leave it. It adds humanity. On the other hand, avoid the giveaways of automation, like a name variable that drops in with a stray period. Skip the generic compliments too.
I also avoid words like consult, advice and research early on. A recruiter, who lives on LinkedIn all day like I do, got a message from me saying I wasn't sure I had great ideas, but I was happy to share what was working for me. He said yes within about two minutes.
Don't chase
I follow up only a few times. After that, I reply when they reply. Chasing an executive the whole time sets up the wrong power dynamic for a consultant or fractional.
Some people get impatient. One person told me, "Clearly you're warming up for a pitch." I explained that I don't pitch on these calls, and that was that. Different personalities want different things.
Run the call well
Send a scheduling link, or schedule by hand, which shows a bit more effort. Before each call I spend 5 to 10 minutes on homework: their website, their profile, sometimes a quick AI summary, and notes in my CRM.
On the call, take the lead. I use Fathom as a notetaker, and it shows how much of the time I'm talking. I want that number as low as possible, and I can still guide the conversation. Pick up the topic from the DM, and near the end ask whether they know someone you might be able to help.
If you want help starting more of these conversations, that is what my LinkedIn networking service does.
