Two kinds of trust
When people hear strategic networking, a lot of them picture the groups where everyone has to bring two leads to every meeting. There is a place for those, and if one works for you, fantastic. It is just not where I see the best networking happen.
On a networking call, I never want the other person to feel like I am only helping them so they will help me. That is distinctly inauthentic, and people can feel it. Nobody refers a friend to someone who treated them like a trade.
Researchers have put numbers on why so many people dislike networking. In a 2014 paper in Administrative Science Quarterly, Tiziana Casciaro, Francesca Gino and Maryam Kouchaki found that networking done purposely for professional gain can make people feel morally dirty. In their survey of lawyers at a large North American firm, the ones who felt that way networked less often and performed worse. Their 2016 Harvard Business Review article, Learn to Love Networking, suggests thinking about what you can give. That matches my experience. When the call is genuinely about helping, it doesn't feel dirty at all.
Never bait and switch
When someone agrees to a call with a person they barely know, they are rolling the dice. They are investing their time, and they decided ahead of time that you were probably worth it. If you get on the call and pitch, you basically lied about why you were there, and they lost their gamble.
If the real goal is referrals and introductions, think about what that means. You would never refer someone who just lied to you. So on the call you need to be the kind of person they would be glad to introduce to someone they care about.
Set the table before the call
Before we ever meet, I try to start the conversation on something related to my area of expertise. Then the call just continues down that path. There is no surprise and no switch, and it is the topic where I can actually help the most.
Be careful with probing questions. As a marketing person I might ask what marketing challenges someone is dealing with. Asked the wrong way, that sounds like you are setting up a pitch.
Be careful with the word problem, too. I have lost count of the founders and executives who will not admit they have one. I once mentioned helping someone with a problem and he told me, "We don't have any problems." That ended that thread. Challenge works much better.
Leave room in the ask
At the end of a networking call I say briefly what I do and the kind of results I usually get, and I ask if they know someone I could help. If there is any chance the other person might want to work with me, they bring it up themselves, almost every time.
Be clear about who you help, but do not box yourself into a menu. If you spell out exactly three productized services, you may have just excluded yourself from a lot of work they would have asked about.
When a referral does come, the next call is different. You can be much more direct. "Joe mentioned you have some challenges with this. Tell me what's going on." That is a discovery call, and that is fine, because now they expect it.
Warm up a cold target first
Sometimes there is a company you really want to work with and nobody to introduce you. If I had a list of 30 companies like that, I would find out which decision makers are active on LinkedIn. Then I would comment on and interact with their posts for a couple of weeks. No connection request and no InMail yet.
After that, send the connection request and mention that you have enjoyed the back and forth in their comments. In my experience almost everyone accepts at that point, and from there you can move into direct messages and a real networking conversation instead of a cold pitch. If you want help starting those conversations, book a networking chat.
