The pause everyone knows
Networking is a big part of my job. I talk to people, help where I can, and hope for introductions and work. Like most people in my position, I belong to a number of online networking groups, and many of their meetings follow the same pattern. There is some group discussion, maybe a speaker, and then everyone gets sent into small breakout rooms to talk with a few other members.
If you have done this, you know what comes next. About nine times out of ten, there is an awkward pause the moment the room opens. It feels like nobody really wanted to be there, nobody is officially in charge, and nobody knows what to do next. I have seen it a lot.
Why nobody speaks first
That silence is not because the people in the room are rude or uninterested. Psychologists have a name for what is going on. In a classic 1968 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, John Darley and Bibb Latané found that people who believed they were the only one who heard someone in trouble reported it 85% of the time. When they believed four others were also listening, only 31% did. They called it diffusion of responsibility: when a job belongs to everyone, each person feels less responsible for it.
A breakout room is a very low stakes version of the same thing. Everyone can see that someone should start talking, and everyone quietly assumes someone else will.
What the platforms should do
My first proposal is for the video platforms. The ones I use do not do this today, but when breakout rooms open, the software should automatically name one person in each room as the facilitator. Whoever gets picked has the job of starting the conversation and keeping it moving.
I realize that would be harder for some people than for others. I still think every room would be better off with an official facilitator than with no one in charge. So if anyone at Zoom, Teams or the rest is listening, that is my request.
What you can do in the meantime
Since I doubt that feature is coming soon, my second proposal is for you. The next time you land in one of these rooms, do everyone a favor and step up to the plate. Facilitate it yourself.
That does not mean you have to talk more. In fact, you can probably talk less. Be friendly and invite people in. "Hey Bob, what's going on with you? How's business?" Or, "I haven't met you before. What do you do?" Simple questions like that get things moving, and then your job is mostly to listen and pass the conversation around.
If you worry about how that will come across, the research is on your side. In a 2018 paper in Psychological Science, Erica Boothby, Gus Cooney, Gillian Sandstrom and Margaret Clark found that after people talk with someone new, they consistently underestimate how much the other person liked them and enjoyed their company. They called it the liking gap. You are probably coming across better than you think.
I think everyone in the room will be thankful you broke the ice. And the person who makes a room comfortable is the one people remember when an introduction or a project comes up. For more on getting value from these groups, read when networking outreach pays for itself.
